While The Athletic is recognized for high-quality, in-depth sports journalism, it has a significant reputation for predatory and difficult subscription management practices. Many customers report being unable to cancel, experiencing unexpected auto-renewals without notice, and receiving poor support when seeking refunds. If you choose to use the service, it is highly recommended to check if you already have access through a New York Times bundle to avoid paying extra, and to be extremely cautious about auto-renewal settings.
Video reviews
Pros
- Highly regarded, in-depth sports journalism and beat reporting
- Ad-free reading experience for subscribers
- Access to a wide range of podcasts and audio content
Cons
- Difficult and frustrating cancellation processes
- Widespread reports of unauthorized or unexpected auto-renewal charges
- Lack of clear renewal notifications for annual plans
- Poor customer service responsiveness regarding refund requests
- Confusing subscription management when bundled with NYT or third-party platforms like Apple
⚠ Red flags
- Numerous customer complaints regarding unexpected and unauthorized auto-renewals
- Reports of websites offering misleadingly difficult cancellation paths
- Strong patterns of complaints regarding lack of refunds for renewal charges
Safety signals
Third-party ratings
Facts
Better options
Why switch: If you already subscribe to NYT All Access, you likely already have access to The Athletic. Bundling provides better value than paying for a standalone subscription separately.
Better if you are looking for video content and live sports streaming rather than just written sports journalism.
Better for casual fans who do not require deep-dive analysis or ad-free experiences and want to avoid subscription costs.
Based on 8 sources
The Athletic Media Company | BBB Reviews | Better Business BureauThe Athletic HQ Reviews | Read Customer Service Reviews of theathletic.comThe Athletic Terms of Service Analysis | News Subscription ToS Review | ToS WatchdogThe Athletic UK Reviews 46The Athletic HQ Reviews 255The Athletic Review 2026 – Worth It? | SportBot AIThe Athletic NPS & Customer Reviews | ComparablyThe Athletic Review 2026: Honest Pros, Cons & Alternatives | ClickOff.Buyer reports
No buyer reports yet — bought from here? Be the first to share.
Comments are screened before they appear. The count updates immediately.
Checked 1h ago.
Show your live HasTrust score on your own site — it links back here so visitors can see the full check. How it works ↗
